[Science] Stem Cell Research, Controversy, Noble Prize 2012

SubscribeScience41 Comments

IAS Mock Interviews

This is a guest post by Mr.Manikandan Soundararajan

  1. Nobel Prize for Physiology/Medicine (2012):
  2. What are Stem cells?
  3. Where are Stem cells found?
  4. What are the application of Stem cells?
  5. Organ transplant and stem cells
  6. Controversy surrounding stem cells:
  7. Stem Cell research in USA
  8. Stem Cell : Pro and Anti Arguments
  9. Birth to Death- Not only you, your cell also grows:
  10. Significance of Gurdon and Yamanaka’s Discovery
  11. Conclusion:

Nobel Prize for Physiology/Medicine (2012):

  • Given to John B. Gurdon and Shina Yamanaka for their discovery that differentiation of cells is a reversible process (explained below).

What exactly are they talking about?

  1. To understand we need some preliminary info regarding human reproduction and development process.
  2. Humans reproduce sexually i.e. require two parents (need a sperm and an egg)
  3. The sperm fuses with the egg to form a fused product called zygote. This cell divides itself to develop in to a baby.
  4. Now here it is seen that we have only one cell (we know cells similar to brick of a wall, are bricks of our body) zygote, which develops the entire human having eyes, heart, lungs etc. i.e. one cell capable of producing an organism= totipotency (potential to develop a total organism).
  5. There are some other cells which have the capability to produce limited types of tissues, some which can produce only one specific tissue based on which we classify them.. Look into the figure for the classification.

What are Stem cells?

  • Definition wise a stem cell should be:
  • Able to divide and differentiate itself into specialized cells.
  • Importantly should have the capability of self-renewal, i.e. reproduce itself.

Where are Stem cells found?

  • Usually human embryo is a very good source, where all cells are totipotent.
  • Stem cells are also present in adults called adult stem cells or somatic cells. These cells are found in bone marrow [a very popular source], blood etc.
  • These cells do the important function of replenishing tissues, to be simple replacing dead cells.

What are the application of Stem cells?

  • Stem cells can be potentially used to replace diseased cells, lost cells [malfunctioning heart, trachea etc.].
  • A cure for Parkinson like diseases [A degenerative disorder caused by cell death in brain]
  • Type I diabetes can also have a cure with stem cells.
  • Cure for blood cancer- leukemia.
  • And another most important application in organ transplants.

Organ transplant and stem cells

  • We have heard something called antibodies, some antigens, some WBCs(Police force of the body, ring a bell?? 8th class science). In higher classes, we were told, X has a kidney failure, needs kidney transplant to survive, but the kidney has to be from a blood relative else organ rejection will occur!
  • The actual story here: Our body has its own frontline defense white blood corpuscles, which do not allow any foreign national whatsoever in to its boundaries. So an outsider kidney=alien, rejected entry, so the only way is to get a replacement from relative. In this application stem cells are a sustainable replacement

Controversy surrounding stem cells:

  • Stem cells were essentially sourced from human embryos in the beginning, which required embryonic cells. But some people saw this as killing of a child and charged it as murder.
  • Also religious institutions resented to the use of embryos for research.
  • Use of adult stem cells face the difficulty in extraction.

Stem Cell research in USA

US is one country where issues surrounding stem cells and their therapeutic usage are complex:

  • State funding in stem cell & embryonic research was common in US
  • Problems started with legalizing abortions in 1973.
  • Now fearing that further state funding would encourage abortions, women especially poor and vulnerable would be exploited ban was placed on state funding on researches involving human embryos.
  • As usual private, scientist lobby and great range of possibilities like a cure for parkinson’s, blood cancer , cardio problems with the loophole of lack of regulation in private sector all forced the government to lift the ban in 2001.
  • Bush administration was behind this policy framework, which got critics from churches, anti-abortion movements, general public.
  • Even now US has only partially lifted the ban still a moratorium remains, whereby embryos created solely for research only can get state funding.

Stem Cell : Pro and Anti Arguments

  1. Promising cure for various ailments.
  2. Private practice unregulated, so no use closing state practice
  3. Conversion ratio of an embryo into living being very low, the remains are as of now wasted.
  4. So better we put them to use
  5. Organ donation incases of brain death legal, and to think organ donation can increase murders=foolish
  6. Similarly thinking embryo donation=increased abortion is foolish
  1. Legally Embryo the day it is formed= Human life, so it enjoys all rights,like Art 21=Right to life[Indian scenario]
  2. Embryo sale can start, poor can be exploited easily.
  3. Not an Inclusive Plan as such, poor will stay out of reach of benefits.
  4. Ill effects of cloning like break of social fabric,
  5. misuse in the hands of terrorists etc bound to happen
  6. Not a panacea to all ills as it is made out to be. Experimental results as of now are not reliable.
  • Thus there was a need for pluripotent and totipotent cells for various purposes and that too bypassing all the above ill effects.
  • It is here the two laureates [Gurdon and Yamanaka] came in with their contributions.
  • Now Let’s try to understand what they did in simpler terms.

Birth to Death- Not only you, your cell also grows:

  • In Life the cells of an organism proceed from initial undifferentiated stage to mature specialized stage through the process of differentiation, like a student in schools, ‘studies science, history, geography, English’ while during graduation narrows his focus only to his ‘subject of specialization’, during doctorate further narrowed thought to ‘one area in a subject’!!
  • Similar to this our cells at birth manage all functions, with maturity they specialize: eye cells for vision, heart cells for purification, pumping etc. And this natural process is irreversible, that is once they mature, cells never exhibit their magical ability to be the jack of all trades. This was the plight in 1950s.
  • Now in 1960s this person called Gurdon said “Ordinary cells have only temporarily lost their pluripotency and if necessary changes made can become stem cells”.
  • Gurdon proved it in his experiment, he simply took the nuclei (grain of brick, i.e. part of our cells, of course the master of a cell is its nuclei) of a mature cell from a frog replaced it for nuclei in a newly fertilized egg (already told you egg cells=totipotent) and developed it in to a new tadpole. i.e. here the nuclei of a mature cell developed the new tadpole.
  • But the second person Yamanaka went further proving, “no need the help of an egg cell to develop a new offspring, just any mature cell, like that of a skin, can be simply made pluripotent”. His major contribution was he identified the required genes and codes for making a mature cell pluripotent. The result was increased accuracy, efficiency in converting a mature cell to immature cell.[Dedifferentiation]

Significance of Gurdon and Yamanaka’s Discovery

  • Their discoveries were answers to problems surrounding use of stem cells.
  • Was an easy way to convert ordinary cells to stem cells. A reliable source for pluripotent cells
  • No destruction of embryos involved.
  • Basis for cloning, the discovery of Gurdon was the basis for cloning.
  • Yet some problems still remain in this technology:
  • Reliability, efficiency of conversion is still low.
  • If put to improper use without sufficient research can lead to uncontrolled, cancerous growth of cells.


  • Thus we see that these scientists have furthered a revolution and in here lays the answer to many incurable diseases of today.
  • Though clinical trials, human experimentation are not into practice yet, some preliminary treatments like bone marrow transplant, cardiovascular treatments with stem cells have been demonstrated elsewhere is a sample for the success of the technology.

Mrunal recommends

  1. (free) NCERT, NIOS, TN-Books 4 History,Geo,Sci
  2. Indian Polity M.Laxmikanth (Hindi | English)
  3. Spectrum: Modern History (Hindi | English)
  4. Maths: Quantam CAT Sarvesh Kumar
  5. Objective General English SP Bakshi
  6. Word Power made Easy -Norman Lowe
  7. Topic wise Solved Paperset by Disha

41 Comments on “[Science] Stem Cell Research, Controversy, Noble Prize 2012”

  1. Big thanks Mr.Manikandan Soundararajan .

  2. Sir I have heard many ppl saying that it is not possible to be a UPSC topper by writing in a language other than english and hindi.Are the candidates of regional language in some sort of disadvantage?????? Plz reply

    1. No, It’s nothing else then a rumor. There are many students having their regional languages as a medium and yet got a place in top ten list. Most important benefit english and hindi students get is the availability of authentic material, other than that they don’t get any favor from UPSC.
      So don’t worry and keep hard working.

  3. Excellent. Thank you Sir,

  4. hi mrunal. again a great article.

    i request you to write an article on the american healthcare law, which was recently enacted.
    i dont understand the reason for the massive opposition to it in USA.

  5. Dear Mr.Manikandan Soundararajan
    thanks for this article..

  6. Zygote – is the union of sperm and an egg is Totipotent(to develop into a total organism).
    Embryo is developed after the cell division of Zygote,It can differentiate into different specialized cells hence called Pluripotent (it is called germ layers, but lets us say different internal organs).Once different cells are formed out of embryos lets take blood cells, which are single cells gets differentiated into WBC, RBC, Platelates hence the single blood cell before differentiation is Multipotent.

    1. Thanks for the differentiation

    2. thank sir. u also add some terminolgy its good for me .go ahead

  7. Please provide 2012 upsc mains zoology question paper

  8. thanks for explanation in lucid manner.

  9. @ARUN
    is it relevant..????????

  10. I have the following doubts.Please clarify.
    1.concept of fungible floor space index in context with real estate industry in india.
    2.Recent approval to MCX-SX for launching platform in stock trading help in indian captial markets.
    3.Background and current issues with the HOUSE OF THE LORDS REFORM BILLS OF U.K.

    Thank you

    1. dont u think u r geting too technical…newyz i dont have much of idea

  11. excellently written……!!!! hats off to u…..do keep on coming with such lucidly written articles…i also want to thank you as ur blog helped me a lot during mains this year ,thanks a lot

  12. thank u sir .
    bcoz for new student those also d’nt biology but read the above information i and my friend understand easly.

  13. Thanks Sir for such a nice representation.

  14. Sir, Mrunal its my special request….Please help me any information regarding MPA TEE Exam Time Table December 2012 IGNOU(Subject code-011, 12, 13, 14). I think the time table must be already disclose to the students but I find difficult to assesa it. THANKS!

    1. the time table will be given in hallticket/admit card, which comes through post.

      1. But Sir I haven’t receive Hall Ticket yet. Around what time ideally Hall ticket may be dispatched to me…. Is it normal that I donot receive Hall Ticket till now???

          1. Thanks Sir!

  15. But Sir I haven’t receive Hall Ticket yet. Around what time ideally Hall ticket may be dispatched to me…. Is it normal that I donot receive Hall Ticket till now???

  16. hi mrunal…your explanation of any concept is simple and straight, gets right into the head. thankyou for doing what your doing. could you please post articles regarding delegated legislation and accountability of legislation with some examples.


  17. controversy has been concluded excellently here.

  18. whaat an idea sirji

  19. sir im maharashtra students and i have been studyng upse since one year.and im doing T.Y.B.Ain english. and my problem is in witch language i will be successufull of UPSC? please tell your suggestion in specific

  20. Dear Mrunal Sir,
    please do update topics under the science and technology section from the Hindu and other sources….

  21. The recipients are Sir, John B. Gurdon and Shinya Yamanaka not Shina yamanaka.

  22. thnaks sir, just the amount needed

  23. I am truly delighted to read this website posts which includes plenty of helpful information, thanks for providing these data.

  24. Hello there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my previous room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this write-up to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Many thanks for sharing!

  25. sir thanks to you……as of now i was unable to understand what is going on in news paper regarding stem cell……a great presentation…

  26. Howdy I am so grateful I found your weblog, I really found you by accident, while I was looking on Askjeeve for something else, Anyhow I am here now and would just like to say thanks a lot for a tremendous post and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read through it all at the minute but I have saved it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a great deal more, Please do keep up the superb job.

  27. As I web site possessor I believe the content material here is rattling great , appreciate it for your hard work. You should keep it up forever! Good Luck. aegfddekcfbe

  28. Purchase Generic Bactrim 800mg Without Prescription in Arlington bdbfbdeeebdk

  29. Where To Buy Cheap Generic Cefuroxime 250mg in Baltimore fddbgcgafbkdfgfc

  30. Thanks Mrunal :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *