[Entry of Europeans] Thuggee in British India, Whistleblower Maharaja Nandakumar, Tipu Sultan

SubscribeIndian-History26 Comments

IAS Mock Interviews
  1. Prologue
  2. Thuggee in British India
  3. Maharaja Nandakumar: 1st Whistleblower of India?
  4. Tipu Sultan and his Ring vs. East India Company

Prologue

  • I’m in process of restructuring new and old articles to make site more revision friendly. You can see the entire Archive at Mrunal.org/history
  • In this page, I’m combining topics of “Entry of Europeans and upto 1857 Mutiny“. For background theory, refer to Class11 Tamilnadu historybook from download section.

Anyways, three topics in (Hindu) news, from that “Entry of Europeans” section:

  • Sep 2014: Thuggee in British India
  • Sep 2014: Maharaja Nandkumar
  • May 2014: Tipu Sultan and his ring.

Thuggee in British India

Relevance:

  • UPSC’s fondness for asking random GK type Qs once in a while- e.g. was Hiuen Tsang robbed or not?
  • Oneliner fodder for the essay: “India has benefitted from Colonialism” (because thuggy was abolished) and even its counterargument – because thugs joined that profession due to heavy debt / jobloss under British raj.
Famous persons vs Thugs
Hiuen TsangBandits attacked his caravan near Ganges. Wanted to sacrifice him to their goddess. (7th Cent)
Jalaluddin KhiljiExpelled ~1000 thugs from Delhi (1920)
KabirUsed thugs as metaphors to show God’s deceit.
NanakHis Janamsakhi texts also mention thuggary.
AugrangzebOrdered execution of Phansigar.

Who were these thugs?

  • Roamed on highways. Trapped victims with drug-laced laddu, looted their belongings and murdered.
  • Main targets: Company sepoys, merchants and pilgrims.
  • Looted horses and weapons given to local rulers for “protection”, and even bribed the city officials.
  • Even used the loot, to repay their agriculture debt to Zamindars!
  • Thugs came From all strata of society. They were not limited to a single caste or religion.
  • Many of them were sepoys in Mughal army, who lost jobs under British Empire.
  • Thuggee was a “seasonal occupation”. They left the village after the autumn harvest (Oct-Nov) and returned June-July before the rains.

Thuggee in British India

How did the British wiped out thuggee in India?
1810East India Company passed a regulation. If Zamindar did not inform the company about thug activities, he’d be punished.
1930Government authorised Captain Sleeman to wipe out thugs.
1839Captain Sleeman succeeded but jailing and hanging most of the thugs.

Ref: September 2014, TheHindu review of a book “Thuggee: Banditry and the British in Early Nineteenth-Century India: Kim A. Wagner”.


Maharaja Nandakumar: 1st Whistleblower of British India?

Warren Hastings Maharaja Nandkumar

  • He was a revenue officer under the Nawab of Bengal
  • Helped British during Battle of Plassey (1757),
Year 1775
NandakumarMade allegations that Governor General Hastings accepted bribes from Nawab and others.
HastingNo, Nandakumar himself paying bribes to others, to malign my image!
  • Later, company officials arrange a ‘puppet’ Indian to file a forgery case against Nandakumar.
  • During that era, Indian vs. Indian cases were not to be heard by British judges.
  • But still a British judge presided over Nandakumar forgery case and awarded death sentence. (Curiously that judge was a close friend of Hastings)
  • Maharaja Nandakumar was hanged in full public view at the Hoogly river banks near Kolkata.
  • Edmund Burke, Lord Macaulay and other eminent British described Nandakumar’s hanging as a ‘judicial murder’.
  • Moral of the story: unless there is a whistleblower protection act, you shouldn’t take on your boss.
  • Why in news: His turban will be displayed in Kolkata’s Victoria’s hall. (September 2014)

Tipu Sultan vs. East India Company

  • Father: Haidar Ali
  • Tipu Named after Sufi Saint Tipu Sultan Auliya. Nickname” Tiger of Mysore”.
  • Kingdom: Mysore, Karnataka
  • Capital: Shri Rangapatnnam.
  • Tipu was a Muslim, but THEHINDU (May 13, 2014) claims he was “Catholic in his religious outlook!

Tipu buildings:

  • Summer palace at Bangalore
  • Tipu did not build the Sri Rangpatnam. It was built by a Feudal lord in 16th century

Tipu Military prowess

  • Wrote a military manual: Fathul Mujhahidin
  • Manufactured rockets, artillery and firearms.
Anglo Mysore Wars
YearOutcome
1767Haidar Ali defeated British
1780
  • Maratha, Nizam and Haider formed tripartite alliance to protect French at Mahe against the British
  • But Maratha (Bhosle & Scindia) and Nizam made peace with British & left fight.
  • Hairdar died, Tipu carried the fight & defeated the British =>Treaty of Manglore 1784. It restored status quo.
1790
  • Governor General Cornwallis made alliance with Marathas and Nizam, finally defeated Tipu
  • Treaty of Shri Rangpatanam, where Tipu gave 50% of his territory, 3 crore rupees and 2 sons to Lord Cornwallis as hostages (to ensure 3 crores were paid in regular installments.)
1799
  • Tipu tried to set alliance with Arab, Turks and Afghans to defeat the British but failed.
  • To create alliance with the French, Tipu setup a Jacobian club of republican ideas. Napoleon was pleased & sent a friendly letter, later a few soldiers came to aid Tipu in fourth war.
  • Wellesley asked Tipu to join subsidiary alliance, but he declined. This led to fourth Anglo Mysore war, Tipu died defeating Fort Sri Rangapattinam.

Tipu Sultan Ring

  • Arthur Wellesley (Lord Wellesley’s brother) took away Tipu’s ring, made of gold, has written “Ram” in Hindi.
  • Later, the British deported Tipu’s family to Calcutta, distributed part of the territory to Nizam, & setup a 5 year old puppet king Manmohan Singh Krishnaraja III @Mysore, and signed subsidiary alliance with him.
Auction of Tipu’s ring and swords
2003Vijay Mallya purchased Tipu’s sword from a London auction for ~1.5 crore rupees
2014An unknown bidder purchased Tipu’s ring from a London auction for ~1.4 crore rupees.

Mock Questions

Q1. As per the Treaty of Srirangapattinam

  1. Tipu Sultan had to give up part of his territory Nizam, Marathas and East India company
  2. Tipu Sultan had to give his two sons as hostages to Hastings
  3. Both A and B
  4. Neither A nor B

Q2. What of the following steps were taken by Lord Cornwallis?

  1. Tripartite alliance with Nizam and Marathas to fight against the French
  2. Gave judicial powers to district collectors.
  3. Removed all Indians from judicial positions

Correct statements are:

  1. Only 1 and 2
  2. Only 2 and 3
  3. Only 1 and 3
  4. None of them

Q3. Lord Wellesley __.

  1. Adopted non-interventionist policy in India.
  2. Was confident that Napoleon will not intervene in India to aid Tipu Sultan.
  3. Played major role in creation of Agra Province and Madras presidency

Incorrect statements are:

  1. Only 1 and 2
  2. Only 2 and 3
  3. Only 1 and 3
  4. None of them

Correct Answers for above MCQs:

  1. D both wrong. Alliance made to fight against Mysore and Tipu gave sons to Cornwallis.
  2. D- none of them. Read Tamilnadu class12 Chapter 2 on Cornwallis.
  3. A-1 and 2 incorrect. Mind it, you’ve to find wrong statements in this question. Read Tamilnadu class12 chapter3 on Wellesley.

Mains/interview

  1. (Interview) Whenever there is auction of items related to Tipu, Gandhi & other prominent historic figures, some Indians demand that government of India should bring back those items. But there is no dearth of such collectible items. Can you think of arguments both in favor and against this demand?
  2. (interview) From British point of view, which Governor General or Viceroy can be considered THE MOST Effective administrator of India, and why?

Mrunal recommends

  1. (free) NCERT, NIOS, TN-Books 4 History,Geo,Sci
  2. Indian Polity M.Laxmikanth (Hindi | English)
  3. Spectrum: Modern History (Hindi | English)
  4. Maths: Quantam CAT Sarvesh Kumar
  5. Objective General English SP Bakshi
  6. Word Power made Easy -Norman Lowe
  7. Topic wise Solved Paperset by Disha

26 Comments on “[Entry of Europeans] Thuggee in British India, Whistleblower Maharaja Nandakumar, Tipu Sultan”

  1. Is it error sleeman 1930 ??

    1. Yes it is. Read 1830, during the period of William Bentinck.

  2. TIPU – SULTAN

    “catholic in his religious outlook”

    -it means he was “secular and universal”, in his religious outlook.

    -just the literal meaning of catholic.

    – nothing to do with “roman catholic”, form of christianity.

  3. Hello mrunal. If you are serious about the “catholic” thing, i.e. if u think it’s not correct to use the word, I would like to clarify that “Catholic” doesnt only refer to a christian sect but it also means “broad in interests; including many things”, etc. It is said that civil service aspirants should have a “catholic” curiosity. It is in this sense that the word is used regarding tipu sultan.

    1. i agree abhay but may be it`s the capital C in Catholic that led him to think that way……so it`s actually an error on the part of The Hindu

    2. it was not Mrunal’s words, it was the Hindus’s words

      “The historical record shows Tipu as Catholic in his religious outlook and forward-looking in his world-view”.

      Cut the guy some slack, he’s doing a great job. I swear you remm everything in his post, way faster than you read any txtbok. Sit back and njoy instead of finding faults :)

    3. I think it could be used when we talk about tipu’s overwhelming thrust towards European ideology …!!!!

    4. Yes! This view of catholic makes more sense. I read tipu was religious tolerant owing to the fact there is a temple mosque and church in his fort.

    5. Surely you have Pub Ad optional!

  4. @raj
    there is no point in asking.. no one is replying to questions on Mrunal these days…

    1. pessimism on the spot..:)

  5. I think its typo error
    in 1830 Government authorised Captain Sleeman to wipe out thugs.not in 1930

  6. MRUNAL sir,
    i am requesting you to pls publish article on NPPA controversy, labour 49:51 scheme,IPR reforms. these topics are appearing daily in indian express. pls

  7. Sir,
    Kindly guide us for the mains by continuing to publish articles on current affairs. I know that it takes lots of time and effort, but in the present situation you are the only hope for people like me.

  8. Sir please guide us for mains.

  9. treaty of manglore was signed when no one got victory neither tipu nor britishers

  10. Please put countdown like “Katl ki subah” for mains also

  11. Lol cleverly placed innuendos mr mrunal,one of the good things about your writing.Good work on the article.

  12. Hello friends I want to join mains test series in hindi medium. Plz guide me and suggest some good coaching centre in delhi.

  13. Sir, Jalalludin Khilji expelled thugs during 1290 not 1920. Request you to correct that.

  14. The word “Catholic” used in case of Tipu sultan means universal/comprehensive.

  15. thank you sir, is it error about saleem 1930?

  16. Jalaluddin Khilji Expelled ~1000 thugs from Delhi (1920)

    He lived 1290 AD, not 20th century.

  17. Gaewak=Gujarat
    Holkar=Nagpur
    Sindhia=MP
    Peshwa=Pune
    1 more=???

    The Martha empire was replaced by the “Peshwas”

    Mysore war=Subsidiary alliance fault.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *