Got this question from mail,
what are these income,production and expenditure methods in calulating GDP?how do terms like NNP, NDP, GNP,GDP,NNPFC,NNPMP DIFFER FROM EACH OTHER. what is difference between gdp at constant prices and current prices. its very confusing
I’ll deal with each question in one post. First, lets refresh the concepts again.
GDP (Gross Domestic Product) means,
Money value of everything you produce within your country.
(Domestic=within country).
Everything means products and services.
GNP (Gross National Product) means,
The Money value of everything you produce within your country PLUS your income from abroad. Anil Kapoor goes to America, get 5 million dollar$ to play baddie in Mission Impossible 4, but sends that money to India = counted in India’s GNP.
But with same logic, Cricket Coach Gary Kirsten gets 50 lakh rupees from BCCI, and sends it to his family in S.Africa, you’ve to deduct it from India’s GNP. (South Africans will count it in their GNP)
Similarly, Americans will subtract the dollar value of Anil Kapoor’s remittance to India while counting their GNP.
So, what’ll be the (stupid) formula?
Gross National production=Money value of everything produced within India+Incoming money from outside-Outgoing money to abroad.
Or you can simply say
GNP = GDP + incoming money from abroad – Outgoing money to abroad.
How GDP calculated and what is are these income, production and expenditure methods.
GDP is calculated by three methods.
Theoretically all three of them should give same final number, but in reality there will be slight difference between each of them.
#A: EXPENDITURE METHOD OF COUNTING GDP
Here you count the money spent by everyone.
So How to make a ‘technical’ formula? Ask yourself, where is the money changing hands? There are five components of that.

#1: CONSUMPTION BY PRIVATE CITIZENS [C]
like you and me buying (overpriced) daal, vegetables and milk (courtesy: Sharad Pawar).
I buy your second-hand bike for 15,000 Rupees, should we including it in the consumer Expenditure (C) ? Nope. Because the bike Is not ‘produced again.
![]() |
| Second hand products are not counted |
When you had bought that bike for Rs.30000, 10 years ago, we had counted that money in that year’s GDP. So second hand-product sale money cannot be counted in this year’s GDP.
Now, I buy your second-hand bike from an auto dealer, (who gets Rs.1000 Commission) should we include it in the (C)? Hell Yes, because he sold his ‘service’ to me uniquely. Every time he sells a second hand product, although no new ‘product’ is created but new service is delivered by him.
WHAT IF SAME 1000 RUPEE NOTE IS CHANGING HANDS?
![]() |
| Each service or product has separate value even if same currency note is used to purchase it |
I gave a note of Rs.1000 to that dealer as part of his brokerage (dalaali) and he gives the same Rs.1000 note to the electricity company for his monthly bill.
Same Rs.1000 note is changing hands so is our GDP =Rs.1000? Nope. GDP is the money value of everything produced within India. So brokerage service is Rs.1000 separately and the electricity produced is also worth Rs.1000 separately. Therefore, Even as same 1000 rupee note is given to both parties.
Total GDP=1000 brokeage+1000 electricity bill=Rs.2000
If electri.co gives that 1000 rupee note to its peon as salary, then again it has to be counted. Because peon sold his unique service separately to the company. So in that case
Total GDP =Brokerge+Electric bill+peon^’ salary=Rs.3000
#2: Investment [I]
People investing in sharemarket, putting money in banks etc.
#3: Government spending [G]
Like buying (overpriced) sports equipment from Kalmaadi’s associates during Common wealth games. Government paying salary to staff, buying new tanks and missiles..everything.
#4, 5 :Export & Import [X & M]
Money we get from export is added.
You remember that GDP means Money value of everything we produce within India. So if we import something, it has to be subtracted, because it is not produced within India.
So formula (for ease In remembering)
GDP = Consumer+Investor+Governer + (eXporter – iMporter)
Technically correct formula:
GDP(Expenditure)=C+I+G+(X-M)
#B: Income Method of counting gdp
Here you count everyone’s income. But some people may be running business in credit (udhaari), sometimes payments are delayed. So may not give the ‘full picture’ for the given year.
#C: Production method of counting gdp
Total money value of everything produced (value added at each stage)
- Farmer produced Wheat and sold 100 kg of it @ 2000 Rs. (Original value)
- Flour mill, purchased it, grinded it and sold the flour to baker @ 2500 Rs. (+500 value added to previous purchase)
- Baker made breads, cookies and biscuits and sold the total production @3500 Rs to its final customers. (+1000 value added to previous purchase)
what is total ‘GDP’ here?
2000+2500+3500=8000 Rs? Hell no! You’ve to see the value added.
So, total money value of this line is: 2000+500+1000=3500.
Not all of the wheat goes into Baker’s oven. Some of it will go in making beer, some in a normal household for making roti and so on. You’ve to track the value added in each different line.
To be continued… GDP at nominal price, Market price, Factor Cost, etc.etc.etc.

![[Image]](http://img685.imageshack.us/img685/3862/bikes.png)
![[Image]](http://img822.imageshack.us/img822/3066/notechanginghands.png)
Your presentation is very nice.
That is, simple to understand and remember!
Thanks!
mrunal sir,i have a query..we know that GDP means Money value of everything 'PRODUCED WITHIN' India..then why should we add the spending on tanks and other weapons bought by the govt which r produced in other countries????
@zico
No we are only calculating goods and services produced in our country only.
@mrunal :- I must say that i understood everything what my sir cannot explain in 3 months… :) Thanks a lot
You've honored me with this complement!
my question is again the same………
HOW U CAN BE SO SMART…..???????
Well explained Mrunal. I have a little doubt though. In the expenditure method of calculating GDP can u count Anil Kapoor's income as u had done in calculating GNP. After all aren't we exporting his skills/services to get that money into the country?
I know a question along the similar lines was asked but i couldn't relate the answer.
Thanks anyway mate.
I am new on this blog, I think…Anil kapoor’s service/skills did not produced in India, so it will not be calculated with GDP. but we can add his earned money in GNP because the definition of GNP is ” goods and services produced by individual or enterprises owned by a country’s citizen”, and Anil Kapoor is an indian citizen. So there is no problem to include his money in GNP but not with GDP.
Thanks Mrunal. I have a little doubt though. In the expenditure method of calculating GDP can we calculate Anil Kapoor's income as u had done in calculating GNP. After all aren't we exporting his services/skills to get that money into the country.
I know a question along the same lines was asked but I cudn't relate to the answer.
Thanks anyway mate
@mrunal sir: thnx for this awesome presentation….by reading this presentation..terms like ….. GNP,GDP…seems like very easy terms .
@mrunal sir: thanks for this awesome presentation……after reading this …terms GNP,GDP,..seems very easy.
It’s a noble endeavour…I feel like appreciating..what should b the approach if one wants to appear for state level civil service exam??
it’s really awesome……
the way GDP,GNP have been explained were really fantastic…n nobody can forget if anyone teaches like this…appreciating u a lot sir,…hope to see many more explicit explanations…
the way of explanation by quoting example is awsesome u r superb sir…
sir,
plz tell me one thing what is national income?
i am a faculty for upsc in pune and teach economics, am constantly following your posts all the time. you are smart, have a sense on need from the people so do i. the only difference in us is i speak and tech and you type and express, which requires a lot of commitment for the way you doing it. WHATS THE SECRETE BEHIND HUH? WHAT MAKE YOU SO CONSTANT FOR WHAT YOU DO? EXPECTING THE ANSWER.. AND ALL THE BEST, YOU HELPING UNCOUNTABLE AUDIENCE OUT HERE.
u r g8 ,how u do this…….
Thank you so muche. Seriously easy to understand and to the point. :)
thanx sir awesome finaaly understood gdp gnp
Sir,
a bike manufactured for 30000. But after one year seller sold it for 20000. so value reduced.My question is in this case how to calculate using 3rd model?
hi mrunal,
l am new to your blog na i have a question in todays newspaper jaipal reddy has said that “anyone who holds oil min will be frustrated because india imports 75% of the oil and not even god can explain why and who is increasing oil prices when there is no disconnect between demand and supply”
please help on this though i lnow that when dollar becomes expensive oil pices go up but still i need a thorough details on this topic.
Thanks
Hi mrunal sir,
thanx for ur simple notes on economy , you have made it quite easy to understand the economys different concepts in a layman’s language…
your articles are very easy to understand and remember…..than you so much…please keep up the good work:)
Mrunal sir….u r doing a great job…making things simple…am a regular visitor…in a couple of days,my economy basic ideas turned into a shape…thnk u so much…
you are doing a humble contribution to the aspirants who are struggling for years or months without knowing whom to ask certain queries.
my sincere heart felt thanks for all the work of yours.
Mrunal,
how can investing in shares or putting money in bank account be counted in GDP?
wikipedia says-
” In contrast to its colloquial meaning, ‘Investment’ in GDP does not mean purchases of financial products. Buying financial products is classed as ‘saving’, as opposed to investment. This avoids double-counting: if one buys shares in a company, and the company uses the money received to buy plant, equipment, etc., the amount will be counted toward GDP when the company spends the money on those things; to also count it when one gives it to the company would be to count two times an amount that only corresponds to one group of products. Buying bonds or stocks is a swapping of deeds, a transfer of claims on future production, not directly an expenditure on products.”
please clarify
in my opinion only the service charges of bank or the brokerage on shares bought must be considered
@mrunal ..thnks bro….could u plz help to understand the concept of gdp in form of different taxes what type of taxes it include…
I salute your efforts..!!..really noteworthy work you are doing
sir,you r doing really a commendable job….all the write ups r really helpful….thanks a ton…god bless!
sir are fiis and fdi calculated while calculating,gnp ,nnp or national income?????