- What was Subprime crisis?
- What was US-Government’s response to Sub-prime crisis?
- What is Fiscal cliff?
- Why is Fiscal cliff bad for US Economy?
- What will be the Effect of Fiscal Cliff on India?
Fiscal Cliff= new kid in the town. His parents are (1) Fiscal Deficit and (2) Sub-Prime Crisis.
Now meet his mom, Subprime Crisis.
What was Subprime crisis?
Subprime crisis is also mother of all problems: LIBOR, Eurozone etc. (atleast partially).
- You’re running a bank/Non-Banking Financial company that gives loans, and I’m basically a loser who doesn’t have the aukaat (capacity) to repay any loans.
- Yet, You (American Bank) give me loan of $20,000, And I give you paper saying “if I don’t pay back, you can take away my house.” This is mortgage.
- Wait a minute, if I don’t have the capacity to repay the loan, then why the hell are you giving me a loan in the first place? Well, Two reasons
- Banks decide Loan interest rate based on a person’s creditworthiness. So in my case you can demand higher interest rate=good for you.
- You’re also speculating that in future the real-estate prices will increase, so even if I can’t repay the loan, you can attach my house and sell it off to recover your loan.
Thus, it’s a win-win situation for you whether I pay back the loan or not, you’re going to make good profit.
Now, Back to the topic
- Like this, you gave $20,000 loans each to 5 unworthy people= your investment is 1 lakh dollars.
- Now repack those mortgage papers (security) in a new file and make a new security paper “anyone who gives me $1,50,000, I’ll give him mortgage papers of 5 houses” = this is derivative product. (Because it derives its value from some other thing)
- See? You are making profit of $50,000 and you don’t even have to bother about EMI payments, interest rates anymore.
- Suppose 3rd guy bought such derivative papers and after few months, he repacks them- makes another derivative product and sell it to 4th guy.
- Such papers are one sort of ‘asset’ (because you can get money by selling it to someone.)
- but as you can see, in above cases, people are not creating any ‘new asset’, they just keep repacking and reselling same stuff over and over to different people. So you’re blowing an ‘asset-bubble’.
- After few months, I, the bottom guy in food chain, refuse to pay loan-installments (EMIs), and I tell the 4th guy to take away my house (mortgage).
- Fourth guy takes away my home, but since banks gave loan to so many unworthy people, there is over-saturation or over-availability of houses for sale in the real estate sector. So no one is ready to pay you even $5000 for that house. = This is ‘toxic asset’ your asset bubble is ‘burst’.
- The banks, pension and insurance fund managers of Europe had also invested in this game. They also lost. So in that way, Subprime crisis played a role in future Eurozone crisis.
- A bank of London named Barclay also lost money in this game, that led to LIBOR crisis.
^This is just a crude explanation of what happened in sub-prime crisis. Otherwise the actual crisis was result of many layers of refined and sophisticated loan and investment products interlinked with each other.
- Anyways, the Sub Prime crisis had negative effect on every sector.
- Stock market crashed, Companies started dismissing local staff (especially those banks and mortgage companies).
- If parents were working in some private company, lost jobs or their salary was reduced= they’d not hire maids or babysitters anymore, they’ll buy less clothes and toys for their kids, they’ll not goto some holiday resort during vacations. So indirectly many sectors get affected.
- More unemployment= less product demanded by those unemployed families=even more factories close down=even more unemployment. Cycle goes on.
But why is it called “Sub-prime crisis”?
If a person has full capacity to repay loan, we call him “prime”. Therefore I’m ‘subprime’ because I did not have full capacity to repay the loan, my credit rating was bad. Yet you gave me loan and ran into trouble= sub-prime crisis.
US-Government’s response to Sub-prime crisis?
- US Government has things like Social Security, unemployment allowance, food stamps etc. to take care of those jobless families.
- President Obama started some federal construction projects (roads, bridges etc.) to create employment.
- Government also bought those toxic assets to rescue the banks.
- The Feds (RBI of USA), decreased its lending rates so other banks could borrow at almost 0% interest rate from the Central Bank and then give cheap loans to needy people and businessmen.
- Gave income tax cuts to workers. So they can save at least $1000 from their salary or profit.
- Same way tax-benefits to private companies, If they invest money in research-development etc.
^President Obama took these steps to increase money in the hands of American people, so they can go out for shopping = demand of more products and services= more employment could be created.
But of course, money doesn’t fall from sky.
- Giving tax-cuts to workers and companies= incoming money reduced for the Government.
- Giving unemployment allowance to jobless people= outgoing money increased.
- +daily huge expenses for keeping army in Iraq and Afghanistan= outgoing money already high.
You already know when outgoing money is higher than incoming money, it leads to fiscal deficit.
Fiscal deficit is a big pothole in the road to country’s prosperity. This pothole can be filled with cash only. If this pothole keeps increasing in size then it’ll lead to very bad effects on economy.
So, President Obama had planned some things in advance to increase incoming money and decrease outgoing money for the Government. These plans are:
- Most of the tax-cuts, tax-benefits given to people will be removed from 1st January 2013.
- For example, earlier the people were given tax-cuts if they adopted a child, invested money in children’s college education plans, or businesshouses invested in research and Development etc. All that will expire from 1st January 2013, thus they’ll have to pay higher taxes.
- Many of Government sponsored programs in space research, military research, lengthy unemployment allowances etc. will be either paused, reduced or shut down from 2013. (More than 900 billion dollars saved at the end of 2013)
If things go in ^this way, US Government will earn 4 trillion dollars in next 10 years. That’ll cover up most of its huge fiscal deficits and past mistakes. (i.e. buying toxic assets, money wasted on Iraq-Afghanistan and most importantly Pakistan).
Ok sounds well and good, but
What is fiscal Cliff?
- American economy was going through bad phase due to sub-prime crisis.
- So President Obama had to give stimulus to boost this economy (tax-cuts to companies, buying toxic assets from banks= examples of fiscal-stimulus.)
- Fiscal-Stimulus are similar to Steroids. If an athlete takes steroids, it will temporary improve his performance and take him towards the peak performance.
- But once you stop giving him steroids, his performance will suddenly decline. It will feel like falling off a cliff. Observe this graph:
What is Fiscal Deficit?
- Fiscal cliff term refers to more than $500 billion in tax increases and across-the-board spending cuts scheduled to take effect after 1st January 2013.
- Many economists say these new taxes and spending cuts would be too much deficit reduction, too suddenly, for a weak economy. It’ll lead to an economic recession.
Why is Fiscal cliff bad for US Economy?
- When people have to pay more taxes= less money in their hands = less money to spend on cinema and Christmas vacations= less demand of products= not good for economy.
- When Government reduces research in space, military programs = many people affected directly or indirectly. E.g. less funds for space research = less demand for electronic instruments, metals, pen-pencil-rubber required in those programs.
- Again, If parents were working in some Government-research program/ private company, lost jobs or their salary was reduced, they’d not hire maids or babysitters anymore, they’ll buy less clothes and toys for their kids, they’ll not goto some holiday resort during vacations. So indirectly many sectors get affected.
If President Obama’s plan is carried out, then
- Middle class families of USA, will have to pay average $2000 more in taxes every year. And $2000 is a big amount given that many people in USA don’t earn more than $40,000 a year. So imagine the reduction in their purchasing power.
- Overall, American public will have to pay $500 billion more in taxes.
- More than 10 lakh people will become jobless.
^These numbers vary from site to site, if it’s a pro-Republican party newspaper or expert- they’d say 20 lakh American will become jobless, but some other Pro-democratic party newspaper or analyst would say only 7 lakh will be jobless.
- Anyways, The point is, American Households and businessmen are accustomed (used) to a certain way of spending and saving habits in past four years and Obama plan will break that status quo = not good for economy, at least for the short term. It’ll lead to a decline in GDP.
- Observe this graph
Effect of Fiscal Cliff on India?
- If American consumers have less money = they buy less= not good for Indian exporters (especially polished diamonds).
- Many American companies outsource their research and development work to India, particularly pharmaceuticals (clinical trials of drugs), software, engineering. If Obama removes the tax-benefits given to them (+consumer demand already down)= they’ll either delay payments, cancel or renegotiate the contracts given to the Indian companies.
- If American Corporate have to pay huge taxes @home, and consumer demand is already low, they’ll try to concentrate more on India and other emerging economies to get new customers (Retail, Aviation, Pension-insurance) = More FDI may come to India.
- Americans already burned their hands in share-market and real-estate, if this fiscal cliff leads to recession, they’ll park their money in GOLD = demand of gold increased= gold becomes even more expensive = bigger Current Account deficit for India (because we too love gold) = Rupee weakens against dollar, because when we import gold, we’ve to pay in dollars= we’ve to pay more rupees to buy same amount of crude oil = petrol price increase = inflation.
Ref:
Especially thankful to Mr. Ken Wilson for his fiscal cliff graphs.
What is the basic difference between Austerity measures and the concept of Fiscal Cliff??
Austerity measures= Reduce Government spending Only.
Fiscal cliff= Reduce Government spending + Increase Taxes(suddenly)
Thanks.
I see Mrunal Back in form. Back to High Quality, High Voltage Articles. :)
Back in form? has he even been out of form? Never !!!
Sir ,First of all Thankq For the This Excellent coverage Of Topic .If The Fiscal Cliff Really Effect The America More In the upcoming Days(2013) There Will Be A inflation Situation IN India,IS There Any Alternative methods Or techiniques TO Avoid This Type Of situation(That is Either The America Take Loan From WORLD BANK to come out from this type of situation)
And If the Demand For The Gold INcreases How It Will INturn INcreases Current acoount Deficit.
Anil sir, india imports more gold so trade deficit increases and inturn current account deficit also increases, because india’s imports will be more than its export value. America cant take loan from world bank because it also leads to current account deficit(CAD)because they need to pay huge interest on the loan taken.
thanks mrunal
thank you sir…great article as ever…i think US (and every country) should regulate the rules of lending loans…only prime mortgages should be allowed…else, US can certainly do what they best do…attack a resourceful nation…and capture stuff to feed itself…
Mrunal can you please elaborate GAAR and GST issues ?
hai mrunal sir.thank you so much for providing more clarity on various issues.i request you to elaborate on Nepal logjam and large Haddon collider experiment.
I want to bring to your attention the fact that most of the students don’t really have clarity regarding obc criteria.most of them don’t know that as per the criterion income limit doesn’t include salary or agricultural income.moreover,children of class 3 officers who satisfy the income criterion are eligible for obc reservationg
for govt employees income criteria does not hold, it’s according to Group(A,B,C)
Thank you Mrunal. Amazing article.
Thanks alot Sir, again really a amazing article :) …
Thank u sir..wonderful stuff
BUT WHY WOULD THE 3rd GUY BUY THOSE ‘Repacked papers’??? What will he get?? Bcoz if Loan-takers paid the loans perfectly,then it may not be so profitable for the3rd guy…
hey sagar 3rd guy will purchase only if he seems any profit at that time because time and place matters.It might be possilble that what he thinks proved to be wrong later and again he has to suffer from loss..:)
thanks a lot mrunal but i have 1 doubt can bankers sell the mortgage held with themselves without taking permission from the court.plz clear this sir or any1 if having any idea in details.
10xxx
what is zero based budgeting?
It is a budgeting concept where the budget for next year is formed assuming that you have been given zero amount right now and new estimates are made each year.
Adv:
1. Each yr fresh reviews and accessment.
2. No need to have an institutionalized memory. Earlier it used to be like xyz dept will get the maximum each yr and then abc the least kind. But with ZBB only performing depts get better grants.
3. Greater enthu for performance among depts.
4. No partiality among depts and states (Grant-in-aids given to states).
Is there any way to download ur all articles of a particular subject (like all economy articles)as a single pdf file?
Dear Sir,I think it would be better to link concept of Quantitative Easing here with this article,if not discussed earlier. Thanks.
Hi people, @susanta you asked to dwonload articles in PDF format,well i m suggesting two ways to do so-
1-Dwonload ‘EVERNOTE’ Software,here-http://evernote.com/ and then use it for clipping whatever page/url/or portion of page you want to save(it is very fast and will save you time from copy pasting things here and there,plus you need not carry the data with you all the way to different place,you just have to log into you evernote account from browser and you’ll see the stuffs you have ever clipped,also if you have android or iPhone or windows phone this will be very easy.
2-This is time consuming but i used it before using (1),if using google chrome,simply press ctr+p,you’ll be shown a dialouge box for printing,now select’save as pdf’ from it and then choose a destination folder,although there are lots of articles here and it’ll require hours to download all of them,but blv me once you have downloaded all articles it will help you a lot as whenever new articles come you just download and read them.
I hope this solves problem of everyone looking for a way to save these articles.There are many other ways but i listed the two most easy methods and i’ll recomment method01
thanks :) … really ur first trick works …
The Chrome Ctrl+P technique gives PDF but with irregular margins.
Better just hit the “Print || PDF” button given on the top-right corner of every article, just below the main title. It removes the top, left and right columns and you get a ‘clean’ PDF file with proper margins, headings and bookmarks.
Very Nicely explained..!!
I want to know if Indian banks are vulnerable to such crisis.is there any preventive/correction mechanism in place with the reserve bank.another question is how could India maintain a positive growth trajectory despite double dip recession.what are the strengths of our economy
Yes our Banks are also vulnerable because of people like Mr.Mallya.
FM Chithambaram had recently said Banks should rather give loans to poors because they’re more likely to repay.
Thanks mrunal sir …
—
A great deal of dependency on your articles throughout the course of preparation
forces me to request you
that pls be with us. :(
_________
[Sir, 1 year back there was an article on economy containing 100 basic terms .. but not can’t find that. Have you removed that ??]
——
Thanks again. :)
Try this link: https://mrunalmanage.wpcomstaging.com/2012/06/economy-definition-of-100-a-z-terms-of-economics-from-bbc.html
R/S i started reading your notes from november,12. before it i was confused how to prepare for GS mainly.your notes and guidance has helped me a lot. thank you sir for being with us .
murnal really a great job.
you deserve appreciation for your efforts.
continue with same spirit.
really enjoyed reading this….truly awesome !!!
toxic assets are those assets with banks whose value has fallen drastically low and have no functionality in present scenario . almost a non performing asset
I THINK ITS ALL GOOD NOT BEST. JUST COPY PASTE JOB.
(BASED ON JUST SMART GUESS)
I HAVE CLEARED UPSC PRELIM AND MAIN BOTH TIME I HAVE TILL DATE 2 EFFORTS REMAIN.
I HAD NOT EVER MADE SUCH KIND OF ARTICLES AND NOTES
THEY WILL SMASH YOUR MIND ON TWO WAY.
TO CRACK CSE.
FOLLOW THE IGNOU STRUCTURE ONLY.
FOR THE GUJARATI ASPIRANTS I MUST SAY GO THROUGHOUT GUJARATI MEDIUM EITHER. “PRELIMINARY ANE MAIN CLEAR KARI SAKSO TO NIMANDH MAA TAKLIF PADSE.
I will pray you get your success soon and will be looking forward for your help just the way Mrunal sir is helping. Knowledge can never smash anyone’s mind.
You have experience of clearing mains twice as you mentioned, it will be very beneficial if you too start imparting your knowledge
i love the data
Thnx to mrunal sir,
It is too good article to understand current position of US Economy.
the best endeavour of this article was the definition of sub prime.
Thank you mrunal sir
You are the best
Umar
kashmir