- Disturbing numbers
- PMJDY: Salient Features:
- Jan-Dhan: Benefits, Pro-Arguments
- Criticism / Anti-Arguments
- Mock Questions
Topics part of the [Current] series
- August: scheme launched
- September week3: Rajanbhai finds faults in Jan Dhan scheme while speaking in a seminar. Taking cue from him, all the columnists have jumped in a competition – who can criticize this scheme more?
|Only 59%||Of Indian households have bank accounts (Census 2011)|
|50%||Of the bank accounts are not operated at all. Most probably those accounts opened part of MNREGA and other campaigns.|
|~46,000||Villages have bank branches. (total villages are above 6 lakhs.)|
|3.3 lakh||Villages have Banking Correspondent Agents (BCA) . But this model is epicfail, we’ll see it further in this article.|
|34%||is the average loan interest charged by local money lenders.|
|55%||Of Rural Dalit families have to borrow money from local moneylenders / Shroffs.|
It doesn’t mean Government and RBI haven’t nothing. Since independence, they have launched many initiatives for financial inclusion- Bank Nationalization, Regional Rural banks, cooperative banks, Banking correspondence agent, Swabhiman, Swavlamban, Microfinance, No-frills account, 25% rural branch rule, Bharatiya Mahila Bank and so on.
You can read more details about them under Mrunal.org/economy – particularly under the [Nachiket Mor] Committee article series. Anyways, moving on:
|Who||Department of Financial Services under Finance ministry|
|When||15th August 2015|
|Purpose se||Financial inclusion|
|Target||Open bank accounts for 7.5 crore families in one year.|
|motto||Meraa Khaataa Bhagya Vidhata|
|3.Literacy||Financial literacy programmes to make juntaa aware of benefits of saving and investing money properly.|
|4.CGF||Credit guarantee fund- to cover losses in overdrafts. (Because some villagers might use overdraft for desi liquor and then default in repayment)|
|5.Insurance||If JDY account holder is interested, he can buy micro insurance product.|
- if you already have a bank account, no need to apply again. Just get a “ruPay” debit card, and you get automatically enrolled into this system.
- Jan Dhan accounts are put under Core Banking solution (CBS) platform, therefore it can be transferred from one branch to another, as per your request.
- if you don’t have any account, open a new account with any one of the following documents: Aadhar Voters card, Driving licenses, PAN, Passport etc.
- If a person doesn’t have any official documents, still bank can open its account- with just his photo and signature.
- But such account will be called “Small account”. RBI has put following restrictions on them
- not more than 1 lakh rupee loan per year
- cannot withdraw more than 10,000 rupees per month.
- cannot deposit more than 50,000 rupees in account
- Valid for 12 month only.
- Will aid financial inclusion, will rescue villagers from the clutches of evil money lenders. You can cite those ‘disturbing numbers’ to justify your “pro” stand in the group discussion (GD) when other candidates (brainwashed by theHindu) try to create fish market in GD by criticizing everything under the sun.
- Could boost household savings rate similar to Bank Nationalization in 1960s.
- Direct Benefit transfer (DBT) money will flow into those accounts (and from there again as “loans” to other needy people.) Thus savings will turn into capital. Subsidy leakage will decline.
- Will increase Insurance penetration.
- Overdraft only after monitoring performance => win-win, rare chances of NPA/defaults.
Prime Minister’s Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) will fail because:
Rajanbhai is concerned that:
- Jan Dhan scheme gives Rs. 1 lakh insurance on each account.
- To get large insurance or overdraft facility, same person might open multiple accounts in multiple banks- one with Aadhar card, one with PAN card, one with voters card.
- Sarkaari banks may also overlook nuisance, in order to meet their ‘targets’. Recall the earlier article on PJ Nayak Committee. Since Government is the majority shareholder in sakaari banks=> Chairman and board of directors have pressure from Government => they pressurize bank staffs to enroll maximum bank accounts so that Modi can brag about it during his Madison square speech.
- RBI suggestion: banks should establish a single information sharing system to weed out such multiple accounts.
- Counter argument: State bank of India has made clear guidelines that even if multiple accounts of same person, he will get only 1 lakh cover. And since all accounts are put under Core banking solution (CBS) platform = duplication / mischief unlikely.
Rajanbhai is also worried that JDY accounts could be used for money laundering and Hawala operations.
- Jan Dhan gives you free accident insurance cover worth Rs.1 lakh.
- But there is a secret condition- you must use RuPay debit card atleast once every 45 days.
- This is not be possible for poor families in remote tribal areas. So, they’ll lose the benefit due to inactivity.
Why this secret condition?
- Because insurance money doesn’t fall from sky. Even if you’re getting it for free, still someone has to pay the premium, right? In this case, Modi is not paying the premium. (Because he wants to keep fiscal deficit low).
- Your premium is paid by NPCI. National Payments Corporation of India owns the rupay card system. Therefore, they want you to frequently use the card.
- Jan Dhan aims to divide entry country into sub-service areas (SSA)
- Within those SSA, each household will have a banking outlet within 5 km distance.
- Since banks cannot open branches everywhere, Government aims to achieve this target via Banking Business Correspondence Agents (BCA) or Bank Mitra.
What’re the Problem with BCA model?
- They get 2% commission on each transaction. Monthly income ~2000 rupees.
- As a result, they quickly lose interest in this game, being some other side jobs. So, BCA are never available when customer needs them. 47% of the BCA are untraceable. (says RBI survey)
- Allegations of malpractice. For example
- For opening new account, they ask separate 100 rupees as ‘service charge’ (although no bank or RBI has authorized such payment).
- Some BCA ask separate commission / bakshish from illiterate villagers for withdrawing money from account (beyond the official 2%)
- For loan processing too, they demand separate commission, outside bank’s knowledge.
Jan-Dhan relies on the failed BC model=> Jan dhan will fail as well.
PMJDY aims to make all scheme-subsidy payments directly to Jan-Dhan bank accounts. But this Direct benefit transfer (DBT) itself is a failure because:
- Aadhaar project is yet to cover all residents.
- Aadhar project facing court cases, because UIDAI is not a statutory body, backed by any law.
- UPA Government had to admit in court that “Aadhar-number” is not compulsory get Sarkaari-scheme benefits=> Juntaa won’t be motivated to get Aadhar cards=> Jan Dhan will have trouble transferring money.
- AT BCA level, Biometric authentication (finger scan) = showing 25-30% errors. So citizens will have difficulty in withdrawing money even if they’ve Aadhar card.
|Dot-A||BCA will get 2% commission on transaction|
|Dot-B||DBT will fail = junta won’t get much money in Jan-Dhan accounts and there are fingerprint problem=less transactions.|
- Join Dots A+B+C = BCA (Bank Mitra / Banking correspondence agent) will get very low commission, he’ll lose interest and service quality will declining- just like those coaching wallas, who don’t finish syllabus if batch strength is low.
- Bad customer experience= People can’t use Ru-pay cards every 45 days = insurance protection also gone = further negative experience = Jan Dhan accounts will become dormant. Households will again resume saving money in gold or wasting on desi liquor.
Misc. Anti arguments
- JDY is just old wine (no frills account) in new bottle (Jan Dhan Account). when earlier scheme didnot improve financial inclusion, there is no chance, new one will succeed.
- Systematic and well planned reforms necessary- as recommended by Nachiket Mor Committee- payment banks, wholesale banks, UEBA etc. But Government is in haste to capture media attention.
- Rural incomes will improve because of other Government schemes- skill India, make in India etc.
- So, People will use bank accounts, even if Government gives them no subsidies / DBT / MNREGA.
- With penetration of mobile, internet banking and digital literacy, people will be able to make transactions online. BCA will become irrelevant.
Therefore, even if Aadhar card, DBT or BCA model fails, it is not necessary that Jan Dhan will automatically fail.
- In bank and RBI exams- MCQs about trivial facts and figures. Example-
- On which day was JDY launched?
- How many accounts will be opened in one year?
- How much overdraft offered?
- What is the motto of this scheme etc.
- In CSAT-2015: they’ll give you a few statements about JDY’s salient features. You’ll have to find correct of them. Only 1 and 2; only 1, 2 and 4….and so on.
Answer following in 200 words each
- “Though ambitious, PMJDY faces certain operational difficulties.” Elaborate
- Discuss the initiatives taken since the independence, for the financial inclusion of rural families.
- Enumerate the salient features and benefits of PMJDY.
Interview/ GD: PMJDY- pro and anti-arguments. And what steps should be taken to ensure its success.