I’ve closed the comment system, because aspirants wasting too much time in debate, rather than studying.
UPSC has uploaded the halltickets for CSAT-2014. No change in exam date. It’s same 24th august 2014, Sunday. No change in exam structure- same two papers. No change in negative marking, same 33%.
Link: upsconline.nic.in/eadmitcard/admit_card.php
Many people getting server down error, so try it later.
Warning
- For entering date of birth while downloading admit card: select year first, then month and then date in the end..else it will not get selected.
- any discrepancy in name, parent’s name, photo then send mail to web-upsc@nic.in
- You’ve to tick OMR answers only in BLACK pen. Otherwise you paper will not will evaluated.
- I recommend you bring clipboard. Reason: Sarkaari colleges and highschools have benches have rough surface and holes. It’ll “injure” your OMR sheet while you’re marking answer in black pen.
- if you’ve applied twice, then Use HIGHER REGISTRATION number while downloading the hallticket.
- If your hallticket doesn’t have clear photo/signature, you will have to bring a photo identity proof viz. Adhar Card, Driving License, Passport, Voter I Card etc. and two passport size photographs one for each paper with an undertaking.
- Save your own hallticket PDF file in google drive. So there is no fear of misplacing/forgetting roll number.
| Paper | Time |
| General Studies (paper 1) | 9:30 AM to 11:30 AM |
| Aptitude (paper 2) | 2:30 PM to 4:30 PM |


IasDream.com is organising a webinar of Rachit Raj for all the students across India to let then listen to Rachit Raj where in he would give some tips, suggestions and share his experience on how to study during the preparation and how to approach the prelims examination. He would also share his ideas on writing skills for mains answers and how to study for your optionals and other GS papers. At the end he will also be taking questions from participants. It is a webinar so any one from any where in the world can attend this at his home/office/cyber cafe. Seats are limited so register yourself early at http://www.iasdream.com
I could also not focus on my studies. My cause for worry is another and that is I have seen no activity from mrunal in last 4-5 days. Hoping everything fine with him.
koi mujhe ekk baat batayega
agar advertise ment mein pattern likha hua hai yoh kya bina nayi advt diye upsc pattern change kar sakyta hai ab
it is a legal question that can be chalenged if the pattern s changed
no legal questions…..upsc will issue corrigendum….
Why not?
The timings can be questioned in courts i believe. After all it’s the Civil services PT. And keeping in mind the syllabus one should be notified well advance in time to prepare accordingly.
So legally it can always be challenged and depends on the discretion of courts to consider or ignore such developments of an autonomous body surrendering to political pressure.
No , whatever has been advertise cant be changed without further notice and that notice must give adequate time for preparation so be sure no changes would be made .
doston agar csat hat ta hai toh humme bhi protest karnaa chahiye
main anshan karne ko tayar hoon :)
it seems as if u r not prepared for g.s. isse better g.s pdh lo.mains me hi kaam aa jaega.bs csat k bharose bethe rhne se u wl hardly get anythng.pre clear kr bhi liya to wht wl u do in mains? nd csat wl not b scrapped,may b qualifying hoga ya weightg wl b reduced.so many sci students hv studied gs,they r not stupid.
wow madam you have insider information of what changes are going to take place :P
Deepali ji apka to sab taiyar sa jan padta hai. CSAT is an Aptitude test and uske bharose baithke bhi kuch nhi hoga jab taq acha bhala GS nahi ata ho kisiko.
Seedhi sadhi baat hai markaat hai competition m.. Or ye sab excuses hain. Hat jaega tab bhi roenge ye log to kuch na kuch bahana bana k..
Aap apne students ko kam se kam aesa na padhana ki rajneeti kaese karte hain!
no.aisa nhi h ki sab taiyar h.bt yes,bina g.s k it’s difficult task 4 mains.g.s to sabhi ko pdhna padega.nd govt wl nt take any extreme step,lik 2 scrap csat 4 sure.may b qualifying or smthng lik tht.so just chill n study.irrespective of ur background,evryone hs 2 stdy g.s.agr last yrs k papers dekhe jaye to karne layak que kr k hi cut off nikal jti h.isliye csat qualifying ho ya jo bhi ho,if u hv studied, u wl make it.best of luck 2 all.
All the best 2 u 2
Deepali aap awesome hein….what’s your ôptional ? Where r u from??
my optional is anthropology.m frm delhi.born in delhi,living in delhi.frst tim aspirant,stdying on its own,wthout coaching.whn peopl hear of delhi,they just think abt mukherji ngr.sorry,bt its nt true.m far frm mukherjii ngr.m not opposing csat bt atleast gv thm equal share.
Great…no coaching for anthro as well?? I also stay in Delhi but far from mukherjee nagar….may I get ur mail id??
i hv nt read anthro yet,i hd biology so i opted 4 it.,seems interesting.email id is vinca.rosea2248@gmail.com
Mr.Ankush first a big laugh at you and your thinking.Tumne CSAT ko kya back door entry samajh rakha hai jiske hatne ka tumhe itna darr hai….now get ready for fair play dude….aur anshan ka matlab jaante ho tum??? majaak bana rakha hai……jiski takleef hadd se jyada badh jaati hai ye wohi kar sakta hai samjhe….GS padh lo…..ye anshan -vanshan “TUMSE NA HO PAYEGA”
@rahul sir csat is nota back entry fr me. agar aapko meri gs pe shak hai toh challenge me i was top in my institute fr gs nd csat mein mera rank 10 tha ok
csatisliye nhi hatana chahiye taki thoda yeh bakwas humanities kam padhni padegi pre mein mains mein toh arte hi hai
or anshan was a sarcastic comment (ab sarcastic ka matlab mat poochna :) )
anshan is in a new fashoin now kisiko karna hi hai toh puraanshan karo bapu ji ki tarha ye amran anshamn kya hota hai
karo toh kam se kam marne walakaro roti nhi khayenge juice peeyenge nonsense
bhai aapke liye humanities bakwas hai??
Super like! In logon ke liye CSAT ek aisa trumpcard hai jiske sahaare IAS ban sakte hain. Nahi to prelims bhi paas karna inke bas ki baat nahi thi. Andhe ke haath lag gayi bater….
jis warg ke taraf aapka ishaaara hai……..wo warg kisi bhi badlaav ke virodh me paijama khol ke nai nachenge…………tayari karenge aur phodenge……………………………………………………………………….
problem hum hi log hoti hai……….hum log ko bhi aptitude aur english ko tabajjo dena chahiye ……………haa translation waali baat vajiv hai……………………………
are yaar officer ban ne ja rahe aur class10 ka english aur math bhi nai solve kar sakte toh @###%%% hai hum par
@pant sir
trumpcard toh hamare liye pehle bhi nhi tha uske baad bhi 2010 mein 40% engineer the
ab aap logon se humanities nhi padhi jaati even being graduate toh hum kya karein
engineer wil rock like this tim chahe koi change karlo :)
Dude.. Anshan karne m koi diqqat nhi hai.. But the thing is we wont have any kind of relevance for the political class. their interests are in cashing politically any issue. jab taq mudde (garibi, bhukmari, berozgari, hindi, rural) rahegi tabhi taq unki rotiyan sikengi!!
We would be simply neglected. But a try is worth it i guess. So m b chalunga boss.. :)
burna na mano to mera ek innovative solution hai……..
english / CSAT virodhi aspirants ko reservation diya jaye… they can have a separate category of any suitable name ..contributing factors will be other categories ..
ST-1 %, SC-2 % , OBC -3 % & GEN-4 % ..total = 10 % for (any suitable name category ) .
It will ensure representation of deprived sections , timely conduct of examinations and continuation of current format without compromise on quality .
no more reservations plz.already ths reservation hs created so much chaos.better ya to gs ki weightage bhi per que. 2.5 mrks ho,or csat qualifying ho or any such sol.nd govt bhi madhyamarg ka hi anusaran karegi.
@Rupesh Hahaha..Its not innovative. Reservation tricks already used by Politicians to lure Voter from decades.
Isse acha m batata hun bhai..
Kisi third-party se(say IBPS) ek online survey karwaye UPSC. Sabhi logo ki mail ID to hogi hi. Ek notification k baad YES/NO type survey karwaye with proper authentication! 1 main sawal ho CSAT hona chahie ya nhi or 3-4 supporting sawal ho ya kuch suggestion bhi le saqti hai(offcourse redundant hoga). Kisi psychologist ki madad le saqti hai UPSC.
And then apply analytical skills and desicion making, comparing proper percentage figures of different language aspirants!! Or nateeje public kare.
Kisi k chacha nana tau hain UPSC m to bolo yar unhe koi rational stand lene ko..!
madhaw lgta h tune garibi nhi dekhi. aur tere statement se tera ego jhalkta h. agr apne aap ko nhi bdla to tu bhul ja ki es janm me tu ias ban payega. bolne se phle soch liya kr kya bol rha h.
@B thanks dude
@ravi ohh this kejriwal nd baba ji (ram dev) kitne garib or lachar hai nd ur fellow pretestants mukherji ngr ki janta ki problem badha rahe hai unki bhi soccho
beta uske liye salo ka dard kai dino bhukhe pet sone ki adat hame to garibi sikha deti hai uske liye tapti dopahri me nange paanv chalne ka anubhav bhi chahiye jo ac room me peda huye horliks boys k pas nahi hota uske liye bachpan se apne garib maa baap ke ashuo ki dhara dekhni padti hai apni zameen benchkar sab kuch lutakar delhi ana padta hai hmari jindgi ti hame sikha deti hai par tum kaha se laaoge wo dard
Dear fellow aspirants,
Todays news in the hindu dat if no major changes in the csat process den they might go to court for directing upsc for scaling process for csat or worse is that they might plea to court for cancellation of the upsc cse notification 2011,2012,2013 !
Though thats a remote possibility but if it did happen den would all the recruitment ll in last three years would be cancelled ?? Highly ridiculuos .
Dis is the height of poor governance. This govt is so weak that started bowing to hindi lobby ( though i firmly believe it has hidden support also of the govt) as first they asked for 9 ques. Them 40 and now full csat. In tv dey say dat dey dont want csat to be scrapped but in processions they say d opposite. Ppl in dis blog saying dat we dont know the issue, i think first dis hindi lobby should articulate their grievance properly first only den we can debate.
Police should take dis hindi lobby wd iron hand !!
I was also reading that editorial of the case of going for the jugular if no significant decision is made! That was utter nonsense.
These ppl are creating nuisance now! And the govt is supporting it’s hidden agenda(hindu hindi hindutva)!
A simple solution would have been to debar all such protesters from appearing in any UPSC examinations …jab chup chap ghar kamre me chale jate……
Debar is remote thing friends, believe me if police wants den wat is d aukaat of dese sudo protesters. Upsc has supreme authority to a great extent. Why dis govt is bowing to dese sudo protesters wen dey are just few in no. Compared to those who ll write dis exam on 24 august. Govt should think for that major chunk as perfection is a utopian concept, n john rawls , bentham all said greater good for maximum ppl though some ll always remain at disadvantage afterall all cant become equal ( this so called level playing field ) .
Even if this csat is remove i dont bother , come what may. But i firmly believe this hindi lobby den also ll stand no chance coz in arts also mostly are english medium student. I think govt should create another services for hindi ppl. Coz here dey cant compete only complain.
do one thing demand a separate desh
Agree
bro Kartick I think you dont read newspaper carefully these protesters are not protesting for Hindi only but also for other regional languages they are giving proofs how students of tamil medium,telgu medium and other regional languages are not getting qualified in last 3 years as u r IAS aspirant at least check d facts
1st regional language candidate to select is Gurudatt Hegde (25th rank). He has written in Kannada language….!!!
“Hindi ppl” ….. Mr.Kartik you should ashamed of yourself….this type of cheap mentality and you say yourself a civil service aspirant…do you know the population of hindi ppl??? All your education and rattafication of inclusive devlpment ends here…….go and **** urself.
Agreed
Government already have created service for hindi and regional language which is state public services.. all those who want give exam in their regional language shall give spsc exams and dont bother India that is Bharat
1st was okie.. but you messed up your thoughts and attitude at the second part.
Lot of hatred was expressed… which is not Good !!!
We anyway wont be able to do anything….. what least we can do not pollute our thoughts and heart. :)
Be Good.. Feel Good.
And the same hindi lobby will take care of the English urban lobby with a steel rod made in a ‘ispat ka paudha'(steel plant).
I think u have well experience of it !
Anyways chill dude !?
Damn i m looking for that ispat ka podha question in last year paper, mujhe to nhi dikh rha khi
police kya kar legi be….sarkar humari hai,,,,the govt is ours P.M IS MP FROM HINDI HEARTLAND BENARAS AND MHA FROM LUCKNOW english urban lobby ki to lagegi ab
Agar paper pali language me bhi karwalo, sincere candidate to fir bhi nikal hi jayega, Baki aap jo kahe vo thik!
Mrunal bhai kidhar gaye ho Tum ? Hum tumko bahot Miss karre na..
Mrunal bhai economic survey m lage hain shayad! Ek hi din m dhadadhad post marenge. Abhi motivate ho lo pichli bar k interview padh k! :D
Mrunal Bhai is busy in Sabarmati puja
http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/civil-services-exam-row-takes-linguistic-colour-in-chennai/article6262581.ece
if the current pattern continues along with pegging IFos also with the prelims then one has to shut down all humanities,life sciences,forestry and other “lesser” disciplines across the country. Sad but true that no matter what other exams do UPSC prelims must ensure a policy of “positive” discrimination towards the humanities and the vernacular languages.That is the right way to go about it and the only way.
is der chance of further age / attempt increase?
and pray tell me about the IFos poor folks…forestry students from sirsi,ponnampet,coimbatore,dehradun are out because some genius thought “merging” the two exams would be a great idea…the kala committee wanted a cutoff for gs and general English in the old pattern not delisting it and make a fanciful merger..now we have engineers and others who just tick Ifos optional killing genuine aspirants and then also make it to the upsc list thus leaving a void and preventing deserving candidates…this time hardly 500 “ELIGIBLE” candidates wrote ifos mains…..great way to kill one more service..next bring indian economic and statistical service also under the ambit of prelims…let there be 4 rank lists with 80% common candidates and an eventually depleted allied services!!!
an era of don quixotes,sancho panzas has descended on us….run run and run and you ‘ll still be run down. it’s wipeout but with no lady jill wagner as anchor….we are going down down down!!!
@Rudra: As if engineers are some born genius!! Merely by ticking on IFoS they can clear it without even having to prepare for second optional subject?? Only a genuine IFoS candidate will be able to clear it and not just any one (Engineer!) who is preparing for UPSC. IFoS still have two optional subjects unlike UPSC where we have only one optional subject.
Even before merging the two exams, engineers and others used to apply for IFoS
and till 2012 70% were forestry and botany/zooology grads..see what happened now.
What’s the point? Then you will say why do those who have cleared CS once shouldn’t be allowed to appear again?
Those who clear IFS or any exam do so coz they deserve to and not a single undeserving candidate should ever be selected. bharti nahi h bhayee koi!! Prove your metal and get selected. Have your options!!
As per UNION ENVIRONMENT MINISTER Mr Prakash Javadekar in Rajya Sabha… DECISION WILL BE TAKEN IN FAVOR OF STUDENTS AND GOVT. ASSURE THIS……
why to go into the trouble of conducting exams n all …lucky draw hi karwa lo ..jiski lottery nikli wo qualified …
Or still better, why not conduct campus interviews at IITs, IIMs, NITs, BITS etc. for choosing civil servants for our country! !!
a 3 member committee has sat over it for 4 months and still they dither….is it their plan like south Africa in the second test against sri lanka to block block and block their way and kill time so that eventually it’s time up and status quo is maintained…they are delaying for the heck of it…..how long does it take??
Hope its in Favor of students who support CSAT… Now we have to, resort to protest, to retain CSAT. Do rural candidates have a birth right and monopoly over govt. jobs.. ?? Even we like to be part of Bureaucracy and make the change.. even if there is pattern change.. their stupidity is their downfall..
no,they dnt have.bt acc. 2 u ,sm of the highly so called intelligent species of IIT and IIM hv ths rit nd engineers hv ths rit.why cn’t u guys atleast support same weightg, engineering students ko college admissn k tim hi upsc ka intrvw letter bhi mil jna chahiye ya???? 2 compete 4 xms is evrybdy’s rit irrespective of rural,urbn or anythng else.2.5 mrks per que in csat nd 2 mrks per que in g.s,is it justified??? not at all.engineers wnt all jobs,bnk,ssc,corporates .now they wnt special favours in civils also! not fair 2 any of humanities students.justice mangna sbka rit h.
Disclaimer : I am an engg & mba and i have been a big beneficiary of CSAT as i have been clearing prelims with ease in spite of low scores in GS(except for last year).
I think csat should be removed or made qualifying. Non-hindi speakers really get a raw deal. They do know english but when pitted against IIM/IIT/CA and other good mba and engg. college students, its not a fair game. They may be slow in comprehending english (though they may be conversant in english) and it matters a lot in an exam of just 2 hrs. I agree language Chauvinists have hijacked this issue, but there is some merit in their arguments. Also in aptitude too, its become highly formula and trick based. Without coaching in numerical and mental ability its difficult to crack esp. when competing with engg/mba. People have argued that its only 10th level but theres a big difference if a person with10th standard ability in RC/quants competes with engg/mba. The argument that they learn polity, geo, history, eco is dubious. These subjects are must for any ias aspirant worth his salt. These are very subjects which figure in mains too. Plus for a history student, eco or polity may be equally difficult as its for an engg. But they too learn it. Anyway the scope of these questions too have reduced in GS, so where is the question of handicap for engg/mba in GS? Some argue that rote learning/kachda crowd is protesting. But b4 2011 people from this very crowd managed to be selected and have performed well. Celebrity IAS officers should look within b4 voicing opinion on TV/newspaper.
If one qualifies for mains just by scoring 50-60 in gs, its a loss for the country as well. Diversity of students is also being compromised as more engineers are streaming in.
UPSC can instead go for 2 GS paper which will give more scope to test candidates suitability for Mains. Preliminary is a rejection mechanism and not a selection. Aptitude Questions can always be included in this paper like it was b4 2011. Few comprehension questions (with suitable translations) can also figure. Its time ‘some’ engg/mbas who have had a backdoor entry into mains look within. Language is not an indicator of management/administrative ability. Its just a medium. Pls focus on GS and stop this name calling which both camps have indulged in. Its just my opinion and i may be wrong.
Whatever be the outcome pls inform us sooooon. pls. its our life!!!
csat gone…see it
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/thumb/msid-14366550,width-640,resizemode-4/shaktimaan.jpg
Never cut a tree down in the wintertime. Never make a negative decision in the low time. Never make your most important decisions when you are in your worst moods. Wait. Be patient. The storm will pass. The spring will come.
CSAT aptitude paper does not test anything significant. The questions in maths and reading comprehension are very basic in nature.However, what it ensures is that the cut offs are inflated. As a result someone who is weak in aptitude cannot expect to clear on GS score. So weakness in one aspect of the test ensures that such students are not selected. People who score more in GS have surely spent more time preparing for the UPSC exams. UPSC as an exam tests rigor and discipline and commitment. That was the whole idea of having an optional subject. It intends to let you choose the topic in which you want to be tested and it will test you on the depth of knowledge. The aptitude paper surely puts students from rural back gound at a disadvantage. I suggest a following solution:
1 Paper – 300 Marks – 3 hours
150 Questions – 100 GS 50 CSAT – 2 type.
This ensures that even if one is weak in CSAT, they can cover up in GS and Aptitude does not become the single parameter of selection. This will be a more even competition. I say this knowing that my chances of clearing will be severely reduced because I got 74 in GS and 180 in Aptitude last year. But that is the joy of competing in a fair system. What is the point of clearing an exam when its a handicap match for some people?
1.Is it a matter of language?
2. Is it a matter of translation?
3. Is it a matter of appearance of English medium/Engineering/Management students?
If its a matter of language, then question paper is set in English and Hindi and Hindi medium students are facing problems then where are the other regional language students stand, just imagine but they are mute.
Also they are not happy with the question which are asked, like syllogism, family relation, decision making (heard when visited Mukharjee Nagar for a book) and the logic they give “kya DM ban ke hamein ye karna hai ki Sita kahan baithi hai aur sabhi mej kursi hai :-)”. It shows they don’t know why these questions are asked or they are making an excuse which will fall in one hearing. About comprehension which is about 30-35 question they complain the language is not understandable. Then its not the headache of anyone. If anyone believe that because their conversation is in Hindi so they know Hindi very well is utter false. They should increase the vocabulary in the same fashion as English student does by reading newspaper/magazines because meaning of pollination in Hindi is and will be “paragan” and its not tough because you don’t know.
2. If its a matter of translation then say how many word or questions but it is ridiculous to say the whole paper is wrong. Its a human error can be rectified then question comes when? and answer is when you bring the details in the light either via judiciary or executive, but you waited till final result even if there is discrepancies so there is no point to shout just few weeks before the examination. Just ask if any changes come on your shout then what about to all those aspirants who are practicing since a year.
3. If it implies the third then you are violating the Art 16 pf Indian constitution. Engineering/Management/Science students face problems because a number of subjects are not in list which can be taken as optional. After reading Engineering/Management/Science subject they read all the humanities subject and when they grab enough marks then people says GEOGRAPHY, PUBLIC AD, PHILOSOPHY etc easy for them. Even the pattern changes they will be upper hand and this is not because they are intelligent but because they practice (Set) a lot since 12th upto degree (In one semester in one subject 45 classes about 20 tutorials and 5/6 presentation-IIT) and you people jumps from this coaching notes to that coaching this book to that book and aspire 100% they read only for 70% and also they are now rushing towards UPSC so even for them there is tough competition among them. Your empire can be saved by only one way, just practice more otherwise infiltration is on high speed.
ONLY ONE PROBLEM IS THERE, VERY LESS AMOUNT OF AUTHENTIC, RELIABLE , MATERIAL(BOOK/MAGAZINE) FOR HINDI MEDIUM FRIENDS AND HEAVY AMOUNT OF COACHING NOTES…
GOOD LUCK TO ALL,,,keep practicing
The fault lies on anti-social protestors (I won’t call them Civil service aspirants). The present system is working fine and is best. The only problem being the translation of english passage. God forbid, if these protestors somehow got into the bureaucracy, they’ll rot the system. Our system needs logical people with practical aptitude. Just because for these protestors, the paper is of “high standard”, then how come they are even eligible to face the stress of the administration ?
UPSC has formed a full-proof examination to test the aspirants and NOBODY absolutely NOBODY has the right to mess-it up yet alone some pro-Hindu pro-language self-proclaimed government.
The fault lies on anti-social protestors (I won’t call them Civil service aspirants). The present system is working fine and is best. The only problem being the translation of english passage. God forbid, if these protestors somehow got into the bureaucracy, they’ll rot the system. Our system needs logical people with practical aptitude. Just because for these protestors, the paper is of “high standard”, then how come they are even eligible to face the stress of the administration ?
UPSC has formed a full-proof examination to test the aspirants and NOBODY absolutely NOBODY has the right to mess-it up yet alone some pro-Hindu pro-language self-proclaimed government.
jo bhi hona hai jaldi ho jye. atleast pata toh lag jaye kya hone wala hai. tabhi hum free mind ho kar padege. last year 2 aug tak prelims ka result bhi aa gya tha.
mrunal sir kaha gye aap?? General DONG ne apko underground hone ko toh nahi kaha.
mrunal sir waiting for ur update
csat will remov and pt date will postpond bcz political power lies in hindi heart land and other regional langauge areas .and sick elite minded dp agrawal will feel slap on his face giving undue advantage to elite kids .food security act covered ppl 67 percantage dont speak english.we want hard administratior not horlicks english speaking kids who just cant contril riots.u ppl dont believe in level playing field shame on upsc whos translation worst they write land reforms in hindi arth vyastha sudhar which is economic reforms how will we ppl give right answere is it not painfull …..
Read this: http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/seeking-a-level-playing-field/article6261357.ece?homepage=true
CSAT will have to stay acc to me, as there is no empirical evidence to show that it is either rural biased or english biased. There are deeper reasons for the perceived bias.
wow!! this is awesome..i had added arihant csat-2 book to my cart..it costs around 775 had come down to 459..now is around 155 !!! phew….it’s a bloodbath out there….quick people….time to sell your csat book chappies!!
Thanks for the update Rudra…
I also purchased it
: )
Thanx for the update Rudra. :)
damn it is 426 again..what is happening??
Latest update…loksabha mein jitu ji kuch kehne waale hai( most prob regarding CSAT..) after t delhi budget discussion…..hope we get some clarity today…
Indians have high degree of hope !!
jo bhi ho yaar…… but jaldi ho….. sala dimmag toh shaant ho……
Remember rupesh,
Hope is a good thing, may be the best of things and no good thing ever dies…;)
Raunka MEhta :aapko aur koi kaam nahin hai kya ? Pure time is blog mein ghushe rehte ho ? RBI mein kaam nahin hota kya ?
Students should change their strategy of studying for preparation of any exam as per the modified/updated syllabus, not revolt against the changed syllabus to scrap the exam altogether.
More weightage to GS paper should be given- agreed, but scrapping CSAT is not justified.
sahi kaha dost NV
CSAT aptitude paper does not test anything significant. The questions in maths and reading comprehension are very basic in nature.However, what it ensures is that the cut offs are inflated. As a result someone who is weak in aptitude cannot expect to clear on GS score. So weakness in one aspect of the test ensures that such students are not selected. People who score more in GS have surely spent more time preparing for the UPSC exams. UPSC as an exam tests rigor and discipline and commitment. That was the whole idea of having an optional subject. It intends to let you choose the topic in which you want to be tested and it will test you on the depth of knowledge. The aptitude paper surely puts students from rural back gound at a disadvantage. I suggest a following solution:
1 Paper – 300 Marks – 3 hours
150 Questions – 100 GS 50 CSAT – 2 type.
This ensures that even if one is weak in CSAT, they can cover up in GS and Aptitude does not become the single parameter of selection. This will be a more even competition. I say this knowing that my chances of clearing will be severely reduced because I got 74 in GS and 180 in Aptitude last year. But that is the joy of competing in a fair system. What is the point of clearing an exam when its a handicap match for some people?
(Mis)Use of Dharna made some1 CM, now let us c how many will become DM! (Disclaimer: DM here is used as symbolic of all 24 services)
http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/civil-services-exam-row-takes-linguistic-colour-in-chennai/article6262581.ece…
Aab dheere dheer sab ayenge apna haq manngne…. Bhaiya ee to puraee super draama bante jaa raha hai..
Gadar!!
and that’s why they should have retained the optional in the prelims and changed the mains as it is now…with time and tide even the prelims could have been later modified..this sudden change has pissed off many!!!
Please please read “navz”s comment….his views are really good